The Instagram Engagement Dip Explained (and What Creators Should Do Next)

In a recent update, Meta revealed that users no longer engage as much in public spaces like feeds and comments. Instead, they spend more time in private chats, group DMs, and niche communities.

If you're a creator and you've noticed an engagement drop, you're not alone—it’s a platform-wide shift. Now’s the time to reframe how you see social success and adopt fresh social strategies that align with this new era of digital behavior.

Let’s break down what’s happening and what creators should do next.

‍

Why is Instagram Engagement Dropping in 2025?

The Instagram engagement drop is affecting more than a handful of creators. Everyone, from brands to creators, is feeling it, signaling significant changes in audience behaviors and priorities.

So, what’s behind the dip? According to Meta, users spend less time on public-facing parts of the platform (like the main feed and grid posts) and more time in private spaces, namely DMs, group chats, and Stories. This new trend towards directly messaged content shows audiences crave more personalized, direct forms of interaction. 

As audiences split their time across TikTok, YouTube Shorts, and other platforms, attention spans are shorter, and Instagram content has to work harder to stand out. Static posts or Reels that once performed well might not hit the same without an immediate hook or clear interaction.

But here’s the good news: It doesn’t mean you’re doing anything wrong. It just means it’s time to evolve. Understanding why things are shifting is the first step to adjusting your strategy and meeting your audience where they are now. So… what should you do next?

‍

4 Smart Pivots Creators Should Make Now

1. Create Shareable, Relatable Content

When content is being increasingly shared through DMs and group chats, your best-performing posts may never appear in a public feed. Shareable content is how you keep growing your reach, even if your likes and comments are down. That’s why it’s critical to focus on shareability. 

How do you know what makes content “shareable”? Think about what you send your friends. Rarely is it a polished brand ad, but instead, a clever tweet, a chaotic behind-the-scenes video, or a moment that feels real and relevant. When you create content that resonates on a human level, it becomes screenshot-worthy, DM-able, and text-message friendly. These shares are harder to track with traditional metrics, but they’re incredibly powerful for building trust and growing your audience organically.

The Takeaway: Build trust by showing up in the moments that matter—DMs, group chats, and beyond.

‍

2. Lean Into Short Form

Short-form content is ideal for shareability, meaning it’s time to embrace TikTok and YouTube Shorts. Unlike Instagram, where much of your reach is tied to your existing followers, Shorts and TikTok actively push your videos to people who don’t follow you. Despite algorithm and consumption changes, these platforms still make it possible for even small or new creators to go viral.

If you’re already creating Instagram Reels, you’re halfway there! Repurpose that content for Shorts and TikTok, and optimize it for the platform by keeping intros tight, prioritizing hooks, and including text overlays or captions to boost watch time. Consistency and experimentation are key! The more you test, the faster you’ll find what clicks with your audience.

The Takeaway: Repurpose, experiment, and stay consistent.

‍

3. Build 1:1 Community Connections

The shift toward DMs, group chats, and private consumption signals a bigger trend: audiences want more meaningful, direct interactions. 

If your public engagement is slowing down, now’s the time to get personal with your audience. Start by giving your followers a direct line to you by creating intimate spaces where your most engaged followers can connect with you and each other. Private Discord servers and a close friends list on Instagram can help foster micro-communities, allowing for more authentic, two-way communication.

The Takeaway: Build private connections up. Give your audience a direct line to you.

‍

4. Monetize Smarter with MagicLinks

With audiences spending more time in private spaces and on fast-moving video platforms, creators need monetization tools that work outside the feed. That’s where MagicLinks comes in. Whether linking products in your Stories, dropping links in group chats, or adding them to your TikTok bio, MagicLinks makes sharing, tracking, and earning from every recommendation simple. Even if your audience isn’t engaging publicly, they’re still clicking, and those clicks can lead to actual earnings. MagicLinks empowers creators to turn casual conversations into income and gives you control over your monetization, no matter where your audience goes next.

‍

Adaptability is Longevity 

Social media constantly changes, but your potential to grow and earn doesn’t have to suffer. If you’ve been feeling the hit from lower engagement, know this: it’s not you. It’s the nature of the game.

By shifting your mindset, diversifying your platforms, and building stronger connections with your community, you can thrive in this next phase of content creation.